Summary: Open source software offers vast benefits but introduces legal risks around licensing, compliance, and IP protection. Understanding permissive vs. copyleft licenses, conducting audits, maintaining SBOMs, and managing proprietary code integration are essential steps to safeguard your software assets, maintain compliance, and prepare for potential funding rounds or acquisitions.
Key Takeaways
- Open source software provides development benefits while introducing legal considerations around licensing, compliance, and IP protection.
- Permissive licenses generally allow proprietary incorporation provided copyright notices and license texts are preserved.
- Copyleft licenses require certain derivative works or covered modifications to remain under open source terms.
- Software audits identify codebase components, license obligations, and any compliance documentation gaps.
- Maintaining a Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) helps teams track dependencies, vulnerabilities, and procurement requests.
- Thorough open source due diligence safeguards company valuation and IP rights prior to funding rounds or acquisitions.
Open source software (OSS) gives you access to reusable code, development tools, and technologies that support faster product development. However, using, modifying, or distributing open source components also creates legal considerations involving software licenses, intellectual property (IP) ownership, patent rights, and confidential information.
If a license permits commercial use, it does not automatically permit every form of modification, redistribution, or integration with proprietary software. You need to review the terms attached to each component and establish processes for tracking compliance throughout the software development lifecycle.
This blog explains common open source software licensing models, compares nine widely used licenses, and outlines practical steps for managing legal risks. It also covers software audits, software bills of materials (SBOMs), and the IP questions that arise during acquisitions and funding rounds.
| Key takeaway: Free access to source code does not mean unrestricted use. The license determines which permissions, notices, disclosure obligations, and other conditions apply. |
What Is an Open Source License?
An open source license is a legal instrument that grants permissions to use, modify, and redistribute software under specified conditions. Two broad categories help explain the differences: permissive licenses and copyleft licenses.
- Permissive licenses generally allow software to be incorporated into proprietary products, provided users comply with conditions such as preserving copyright notices and license text.
- Copyleft licenses require certain distributed derivative works or covered modifications to remain available under the applicable open source license. The scope of this requirement varies by license.
- Weak copyleft licenses typically apply reciprocal requirements to particular files or libraries rather than automatically covering an entire combined application.
This distinction is important as you need to know which obligations apply before incorporating third-party code into a commercial product.
Compare Nine Common Open Source Licenses
The table below outlines the general licensing requirements. However, specific obligations vary based on the applicable license version, distribution method, software architecture, and circumstances of each case.
| License | Attribution and notice requirements | Copyleft scope | Express patent grant | Combining with proprietary code |
| MIT | Preserve copyright and permission notices | None | No explicit patent grant | Generally permitted with notices retained |
| Apache 2.0 | Include license, preserve notices, and identify relevant changes | None | Yes | Generally permitted, subject to license conditions |
| BSD (2-Clause/3-Clause) | Preserve copyright, conditions, and disclaimer | None | No explicit patent grant | Generally permitted with required notices |
| GPL v2 | Preserve notices and provide corresponding source code when required | Strong copyleft for covered derivative works distributed under the license | No express patent grant | Conditional; distribution of combined derivative works can trigger GPL obligations |
| GPL v3 | Preserve notices and provide corresponding source code when required | Strong copyleft for covered derivative works | Yes | Conditional; covered derivative works remain subject to GPL requirements |
| AGPL v3 | Preserve notices and meet applicable source disclosure requirements | Strong copyleft, including a source offer for modified versions used over a network by users interacting with them | Yes | Conditional; network use and combined-work rules require review |
| LGPL (v2.1/v3) | Preserve notices and meet applicable source and relinking requirements | Weak copyleft, generally focused on the library and covered modifications | Depends on version; LGPL v3 has an express patent grant | Generally possible if applicable linking, replacement, and source requirements are met |
| MPL 2.0 | Preserve notices and make covered source files available under MPL terms when distributed | File-level copyleft | Yes | Generally permitted if MPL-covered files and their obligations remain identifiable |
| Practical tip: Consider this table as an initial screening tool, not a final legal determination. License compatibility depends on the specific code, how components interact, and the way the resulting software is distributed or offered as a service. |
Permissive Licenses: Fewer Redistribution Restrictions
The MIT, Apache 2.0, and BSD licenses are popular choices for commercial development because they generally permit proprietary distribution without requiring an entire application to become open source.
However, the details differ. Apache 2.0 contains an express patent license and provisions addressing patent litigation. MIT and the standard BSD licenses do not contain an equally explicit patent grant. Apache 2.0 also requires preservation of applicable notices and treatment of modification notices.
Businesses evaluating open source software licenses need to check these distinctions rather than treating every permissive license as interchangeable.
Copyleft Licenses: Check the Scope
GPL licenses generally impose source availability and licensing conditions on covered derivative works distributed to others. GPL v3 also contains express patent provisions that differ from GPL v2.
The AGPL extends certain source disclosure obligations to modified versions used over a network when users interact with them remotely. This makes it especially relevant to hosted applications and software-as-a-service products.
LGPL and MPL use narrower copyleft models. Their requirements still deserve review, particularly when a proprietary application links to a library or incorporates code from a covered source file.
| Common misunderstanding: Using GPL code internally does not automatically require a company to publish its source code to the public. Distribution, derivative-work questions, and the specific license terms affect the result. AGPL network-use provisions also require separate consideration. |
Compliance With Open Source License Requirements
Open source license compliance starts with knowing which components a product contains and what each license requires.
You need documented processes for:
- Inventory: Record each component’s name, version, source, license, and modifications.
- Attribution: Include required copyright notices, license texts, and acknowledgments in the appropriate documentation or distribution materials.
- Source availability: Identify components that trigger source code delivery or offer obligations, and prepare the required corresponding source code.
- Approval: Review new dependencies before they enter production, particularly components under strong copyleft or unfamiliar licenses.
- Monitoring: Track license changes, new releases, security advisories, and deprecated dependencies.
A company policy also needs to cover employee contributions to public repositories. Staff and independent contractors need clear rules about approval, ownership, confidential information, and permitted disclosures.
Contributor license agreements (CLAs) and copyright assignment agreements (CAAs) can clarify the rights granted to a project and the ownership of contributed code. The appropriate arrangement depends on the project’s governance and the parties’ objectives.
How to Conduct an Open Source Software Audit
An open source software audit identifies the components in a codebase, their license obligations, and any gaps in compliance documentation. It is useful before a major release, following a change in development practices, and during a legal or commercial review.
You can use the following process:
- Scan the codebase: Run software composition analysis tools against repositories, dependency manifests, lockfiles, package managers, containers, and relevant build artifacts.
- Verify the results: Automated scanners can miss embedded code, copied snippets, dual-licensed components, or inaccurate package metadata. Review relevant source files and license texts.
- Map obligations: Classify licenses and record attribution, source code, patent, redistribution, and notice requirements.
- Review architecture: Examine how proprietary code interacts with open source components, including linking, modifications, distribution, and network access.
- Resolve gap: Replace incompatible components, obtain appropriate permissions, revise distribution practices, or meet outstanding license conditions.
- Document decisions: Maintain an auditable record of approvals, exceptions, remediation, and assigned responsibilities.
What Is an SBOM, and When Do You Need One?
A Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) is a structured inventory of software components and their relationships. Think of it as an ingredient list for an application. It can record component names, versions, suppliers, identifiers, and license information, depending on the format and implementation.
It helps teams identify affected components when a vulnerability appears, investigate dependency changes, and respond to customer or procurement requests. It complements a license audit but does not replace reviewing the actual license terms.
Consider generating and maintaining an SBOM when:
- Customers or contracts request component inventories.
- Your company supplies software to government or regulated customers.
- Security teams need to identify vulnerable dependencies.
- A product includes numerous third-party packages or nested dependencies.
- A prospective buyer or investor requests software supply chain documentation.
| Pro Tip: The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) published updated SBOM minimum-element guidance in 2025, covering baseline data fields and practices for documenting software components. CISA’s guidance provides a useful reference for organizations building an SBOM process. |
Open Source Due Diligence Before Funding or an Acquisition
Open source compliance can influence a company’s valuation, contractual obligations, product distribution, and ability to sell or license its technology. Investors and potential buyers need to know exactly what software assets they are funding or acquiring.
So, before a funding round or acquisition, review the following:
- Dependency inventory: Request current SBOMs, software composition analysis reports, and component inventories for major products.
- License exposure: Identify GPL, AGPL, and other licenses that could affect distribution, source disclosure, or product architecture.
- Ownership records: Confirm that employees, founders, and contractors assigned relevant rights to the company where required by their agreements.
- Contribution history: Review public repository contributions, CLAs, CAAs, and any use of company-owned code in external projects.
- Patent considerations: Review patent licenses, notices, infringement allegations, and relevant third-party rights.
- Confidentiality: Check whether proprietary code, customer data, credentials, or trade secrets entered public repositories.
- Remediation: Record unresolved issues, estimated corrective work, ownership, and any required third-party permissions.
These findings can inform representations and warranties, disclosure schedules, transaction conditions, and post-closing remediation plans. For a financing round, they also help management answer investor questions about ownership, licensing, and the ability to commercialize core technology.
Managing Conflicts With Proprietary Software
Open source components can coexist with proprietary software, but their use and distribution must follow applicable license terms, such as:
- Linking methods: Dynamic linking, static linking, and code copying can create different licensing obligations.
- License compatibility: Requirements depend on license terms, software architecture, and how components interact.
- Dual licensing: Companies can offer open source and separate commercial licenses if they hold the necessary rights.
- Containerization: Separate containers do not automatically remove licensing obligations.
| Practical tip: Review license compatibility before selecting a dependency for a proprietary product. Resolving a licensing conflict early is generally easier than replacing a deeply integrated component after release. |
Protecting IP, Patents, and Trade Secrets
When using open source software, you need to protect their original code, patent rights, and confidential information while meeting license obligations.
Open source use does not automatically transfer ownership of a company’s original code. Ownership depends on authorship, employment and contractor agreements, license terms, and software integration.
License types also affect intellectual property rights. Permissive licenses generally allow proprietary modifications, while copyleft licenses can impose reciprocal obligations. Patent grants and termination clauses also vary. Businesses developing patentable technology need to review these rights separately.
Public code contributions can also expose proprietary source code, technical documentation, and trade secrets. You can consider reducing this risk through written contribution policies, repository access controls, code reviews, and clear ownership agreements.
Let’s Work Together: Global Experience, Personal Focus
Open source software creates opportunities for commercial innovation, but you need to address licensing obligations, patent rights, ownership records, and disclosure risks throughout development and distribution.
Ludwig APC assists intellectual property owners and businesses with IP enforcement, licensing, patents, trade secrets, and related disputes. Our team can help assess licensing concerns, protect proprietary technology, and address potential conflicts involving intellectual property.
Have questions about your company’s IP rights? Contact us to discuss your concerns and request a consultation. Call (619) 929-0873 or email consultation@ludwigiplaw.com.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can I use GPL code in a commercial product?
- Yes. The GPL permits commercial use, but distributing a product containing GPL-covered code can trigger conditions involving the GPL license and corresponding source code. Whether those conditions extend to other parts of the product depends on the relationship between the components and the applicable legal analysis. Review the exact GPL version before release.
2. Do I have to publish my source code?
- No, not in every case. Private internal use generally does not trigger the GPL’s distribution-based source disclosure requirements. When distributing covered software, the GPL may require corresponding source code to be provided or made available under its terms. AGPL v3 also addresses certain modified network-accessible applications. The precise obligation depends on the license and use.
3. What is copyleft?
- Copyleft is a licensing model that allows software to be used, modified, and redistributed while requiring covered derivative works or modifications to remain under specified open source terms. Strong copyleft licenses such as GPL generally have broader reciprocal conditions than weak copyleft licenses such as LGPL and MPL. The exact scope varies by license.

